By Mandy Cox
Every day, Catholic employers face deeply personal questions about health benefits that intersect with Church teaching. How leaders handle those moments can either strengthen or undermine the mission of their organization, which is why we are developing CBA Catholic Professional Development and Training for our members.
When Employees Ask Tough Questions
What do you say when an employee asks why your health plan doesn’t pay for contraception—even when their doctor recommends it? How do you respond with care when someone learns their benefits don’t cover artificial reproduction, such as artificial insemination? What about when an employee is upset because their college-age child is being counseled to pursue gender transition, yet your plan doesn’t cover it?
These questions are not theoretical—they happen in Catholic workplaces every day.
Are Your Leaders Prepared?
Are the leaders across your organization ready to have these conversations with both clarity and compassion? What happens if they are not?
These moments touch deeply personal areas of Church teaching. Even well-formed Catholic leaders can be caught off guard when they must explain difficult teachings in emotionally charged situations. Employees are often unaware that your organization is a member of the Catholic Benefits Association — or that this membership shapes their health benefits. They may not realize that working for a Catholic employer means their plan will look different than plans at secular workplaces until they experience a denial of coverage.
The Cost of Unprepared Leadership
When leaders don’t respond well, the impact can extend far beyond one conversation. Let’s look at how that could unfold.
1. Mission Drift and Erosion of Catholic Identity
If a manager minimizes or apologizes for Catholic moral teachings—saying something like “I know this rule seems old-fashioned, but we have to follow it”—the organization’s Catholic identity is weakened. Over time, employees may see the mission as optional or cosmetic rather than central.
2. Employee Distrust and Lower Engagement
Poorly handled conversations can leave employees feeling dismissed or shamed, particularly when the issue touches their personal or family life. Word spreads quickly, and trust erodes. A workplace known for compassion and integrity can suddenly feel cold or inconsistent with its values from one conversation like this.
3. Legal and Compliance Risks
Without proper formation, a leader can unintentionally use language that an employee perceives as moral judgment, possibly leading to a discrimination complaint. Even inconsistent explanations about coverage can create liability or compliance problems under employment law.
4. Reputational Harm and Public Scrutiny
In today’s media environment, one poorly handled comment can be shared online in minutes. A frustrated employee’s social-media post can draw negative attention not only to your organization but to Catholic ministries more broadly.
5. Lost Opportunities for Witness
Every question about benefits is also a chance to express the Church’s beautiful, life-affirming vision of the human person. When leaders are unprepared, these moments become transactional instead of transformational.
How We’ve Heard the Challenge
Our member organizations tell us they want guidance that is both faithful and practical. They seek resources that help leaders:
-
Uphold Church teaching,
-
Connect decisions to their organization’s mission,
-
Demonstrate care for employees, and
-
Offer real solutions to real challenges.
We’ve seen that unprepared leaders not only risk undermining mission but also invite legal and reputational harm.
Now Is the Time to Train Your Leaders
In parishes and dioceses, leaders often have direct formation in Catholic moral teaching. But in ministries further from worship—like social-service organizations, schools, elder-care facilities, cemeteries, and Catholic-owned businesses—leaders may not have the same confidence to train their employees.
These leaders need training that is practical, applicable, and explicit.
Coming in 2026: CBA Catholic Professional Development & Training
In 2026, the Catholic Benefits Association will launch CBA Catholic Professional Development and Training, an online, on-demand platform offering formation for two key areas:
-
Catholic Human Resources
-
Managing Moral Issues
This initiative is a direct response to member requests. Your leaders already bring talent and skill to complex roles; now they can gain the tools to strengthen Catholic identity in your employment culture. With the right formation, your leaders can respond confidently, witness faithfully, and build a workplace that truly reflects your mission.